Easy Spooky Mummy Toast Recipe

You want a Halloween snack that actually gets a reaction. Not the polite “oh, how cute” kind. We’re talking genuine, wide-eyed “whoa” energy from kids and adults alike.

This isn’t another complicated Pinterest fail waiting to happen. This is mummy toast.

It requires zero culinary skill. You probably have the ingredients in your kitchen right now.

The total time investment is less than five minutes. Why settle for boring when you can create a mini masterpiece that’s both spooky and delicious?

Why This Recipe Slaps

This recipe is the undisputed champion of Halloween eats for a reason. The payoff is enormous compared to the laughably small effort required.

It transforms the most basic breakfast staple into a conversation piece.

It’s incredibly versatile. Breakfast, lunch, a party appetizer—this toast does it all. You get to play with your food and call it “cooking.” Best of all, it’s a guaranteed win.

There is no universe where wrapping bread with cheese doesn’t work.

What You’ll Need

Gather these simple ingredients. No fancy grocery run needed.

• Bread: 2 slices of white or wheat bread. The canvas for your undead masterpiece.
• Cheese: 2-3 slices of mozzarella or provolone.
  

  String cheese works in a pinch.

  
  
• Base Spread: 2 tbsp cream cheese, mayonnaise, or mashed avocado.
• Eyeballs: 2 large olive slices, capers, or mini pepperonis with a dot of cream cheese.
• Optional Garnish: Everything bagel seasoning, red pepper flakes, or a sprinkle of paprika for “bandage” color.

How to Make Your Mummy Toast: A Step-by-Step Guide

Follow these steps. Do not overcomplicate this. It’s cheese on bread.

1. Toast the Bread: Lightly toast your bread slices.
   

   You want them firm, not rock-hard. This provides a stable base that won’t get soggy.

2. Apply the Base Layer Spread your cream cheese, mayo, or avocado evenly across the toast. This is the “glue” and adds a flavor base.
   

   Pro tip: avocado makes it a healthier monster.

3. Create the Mummy Wrap Tear your cheese slices into uneven, ragged strips. This is key. Perfect strips are for sandwiches, not mummies.
   

   Lay them haphazardly across the toast, leaving a small gap for the eyes.

4. Melt the Bandages Place the toast under a broiler or in a toaster oven for 60-90 seconds. Watch closely! You want the cheese just melted and bubbly, not a burnt offering to the underworld.
5. Add the Eyes Immediately press your olive or caper “eyes” into the gap you left.
   

   The warmth from the toast will help them adhere. Now your mummy can see its delicious fate.

Storing Your Creations

Let’s be real, this is not a make-ahead meal. Mummy toast is best served immediately, warm and gooey.

The cheese will congeal and the toast will soften if you try to store it.

If you absolutely must prep something, you can tear your cheese strips and have your “eyes” ready to go. Assemble and broil right before serving. Your future self will thank you for not creating refrigerated bread soup.

Why This Recipe is a Total Win

The benefits are obvious.

It’s a quick, low-cost activity that gets kids involved in the kitchen. They can tear the cheese and place the eyes—minimal mess, maximum fun.

It’s also highly customizable for picky eaters and dietary needs. Gluten-free bread?

Vegan cheese? You can make it work. You’re not just making a snack; you’re making a core Halloween memory.

And it’s way cheaper than a store-bought decoration.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Even the simplest spells can be botched. Here’s how to avoid a kitchen catastrophe.

• Over-toasting the Bread: You’re making toast, not a roofing tile. If your bread is too dark before broiling, the cheese will melt into a charred mess.
• Using Thick Cheese: Thick cheddar slices won’t melt into nice bandages.
  

  They’ll just sit there, mocking you. Stick with thinner, meltier cheeses like mozzarella.

• Skipping the Base Layer: Without the cream cheese or avocado, you just have melted cheese on toast. It’s fine, but it’s not a masterpiece.
  

  The base adds crucial flavor and moisture.

• Walking Away from the Broiler: This is the biggest fail. Cheese goes from perfectly melted to incinerated in seconds. Don’t blink.

Spooky Alternatives & Swaps

Feel like mixing it up?

The undead are flexible.

• Pizza Mummy: Use pizza sauce as the base, cheese strips, and pepperoni eyes for a savory option.
• Sweet Mummy: Spread Nutella or peanut butter, use strips of marshmallow or white chocolate, and add candy eyeballs.
• Bagel Mummy: Swap the toast for a halved bagel. It’s a heartier vessel for your cheesy bandages.
• Vegan Mummy: Use vegan cream cheese and your favorite plant-based cheese that melts well. FYI, not all of them do, so choose wisely.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make this without a broiler?

Yes, but it’s trickier.

You can carefully use a microwave in 10-second bursts to melt the cheese. The result won’t be as golden or crispy, but it will still taste good. A hot pan with a lid can also work to steam-melt the cheese.

My cheese didn’t melt into strips.

What happened?

You likely used a cheese that doesn’t have great melting properties, like a pre-shredded bagged cheese (it’s coated in anti-caking agents) or a very aged cheddar. Stick with fresh, soft cheese slices for the best flow.

What’s the best type of olive to use for the eyes?

Large, pitted black olives are the GOAT for this. They’re easy to slice, the perfect size, and their dark color pops against the white cheese.

Capers are a great smaller alternative if you’re making mini mummies.

Can I add meat to this recipe?

Absolutely. A layer of thinly sliced ham or turkey under the cheese strips adds protein and makes it a more substantial meal. Just don’t hide the eyes.

Even mummies need to see.

Final Thoughts

This isn’t just food. It’s an experience. It’s the easiest way to inject a dose of fun and spookiness into your day without any stress.

The barrier to entry is non-existent.

You have permission to play with your food. So go raid your fridge, turn on that broiler, and create something that’s equal parts creepy and cheesy. IMO, that’s what Halloween is all about.

Print